There are a ton of dental dog treats in the market, and many people believe that these types of treats are just like any other. However, dental treats are essential for a dog’s oral health and overall diet for many reasons, including fresh breath. The various brands of dental treats are made to do the same things, but there are some differences that could contribute to your decision. For example, the ingredients vary from brand to brand, so it’s important to identify the key ingredients. Whimzees and Greenies are two popular choices when it comes to canine dental chews.

Making the choice between the two may not be so easy if you’re just comparing them at the store. That’s where we come in! We are going to compare Whimzees and Greenies, so you can decide more easily what is best for your dog. We’ll provide you with the pros and cons of each, the ingredients, the price, and more! The next time you go to the store you will be able to make a confident choice of either Whimzees or Greenies for your precious pup!

Pros of Whimzees Dog Dental Chews

Whimzees are made by a company of dog lovers who also love out planet and want to protect it! Their mission is to introduce pet parents to products that are not only fun, but provide health benefits as well, and to do so in a way that’s socially responsible. We like these dental chews because they don’t offer boring shapes. Whimzees come in various exciting shapes, like hedgehogs and alligators! These treats will make cleaning your dog’s teeth way easier and a lot more fun!

Key Benefits:
  • Edible, vegetarian, gluten-free dental treat is a healthy option for dogs with gluten intolerance or food sensitivities.
  • Ensures proper blood flow through the gums and prevents bad breath and tartar buildup.
  • Textures allows the teeth to easily grip and chew, with grooves that get in between the smaller spaces.
  • Low fat and rich in vitamins and antioxidants, plus fiber to promote regularity and aid in good digestive health.
  • Produced sustainably with no artificial ingredients, colors, flavors or preservatives or GMOs, gluten or meat.

The texture makes dogs want to sink their teeth into Whimzees, which is great for us pet owners because they are designed to promote tooth and gum health. They feature grooves that work their way into small crevices between dog’s teeth, and raised nubs that massage the gums for proper blood flow. Plus, they are low in fat, and gluten free!

Cons of Whimzees Dog Dental Chews

Not everyone is going to love every dog product out there. So, we’ve researched what people had to say about the cons of Whimzees Dog Dental Chews. Here are some of the drawbacks we have seen from pet owners who have purchased these dental chews.

Disadvantages:
  • Dogs with small or fragile teeth (like elderly dogs) can find these treats to be too hard to chew.
  • Some pet owners say the price is a bit expensive for what you get.
  • Not long lasting for tough chewers.

Pros of Greenies Dental Dog Treats

Next, we have Greenies Dental Dog Treats. These chews boost dental health with all-natural ingredients for complete and balanced nutrition. They are designed to control and remove disease-causing plaque and tartar and finally put an end to smelly breath! Additionally, they are recommended by Veterinarians because they are proven to cleans dog’s teeth and gums.

Key Benefits:
  • Recommended by veterinarians to help prevent gum disease, freshen breath and reduce the frequency of professional dental cleanings.
  • Fortified with added vitamins and minerals to deliver complete and balanced nutrition.
  • Made with soluble, all-natural ingredients that easily break down for safe and easy digestion.
  • Proudly made in the USA and accepted by the Veterinary Oral Health Council to support doggy oral health.

Not only are these chews great for oral health, but they are also great for dog’s overall health. The ingredients in Greenies break down quickly for easy digestion and are only 15 calories per treat! We like Greenies Dental Dog Treats because they have a ton of different chews for different health issues. For example, they have weight management treats, joint health treats, and grain-free recipes. Greenies make their treats with all pet needs in mind, which is awesome for us!

Cons of Greenies Dental Dog Treats

Just like the Whimzees, Greenies have their drawbacks as well for some dogs and pet owners. Here are some cons of Greenies Dental Dog Treats.

Disadvantages:
  • Has caused allergies in dogs, so be sure to get grain-free options if your dog has food sensitivities or allergies.
  • Recommended to give your dog one each day, not just as an occasional treat.

Greenies Dental Treats have also had many recalls due to its formula. There have been reports of dogs swallowing them whole instead of chewing on them. It turned out that the ingredients in the Greenies did not dissolve in the dogs digestive tract.

However, Greenies changed their ingredients so if a dog would swallow it whole, the Greenies will now dissolve. They also made them into a bendier chew, but still offers the chewing experience needed for dental support. Since then, there have been no reports of any dangerous concerns.

Nutritional Info

Now, for the most important factor when considering a dog treat – the ingredients. This is a make or break for most pet owners, because we want the best quality ingredients for our pooches! So, lets break down each dental chew so you can see what really goes into your dog’s body!

Whimzees Ingredients

The thing we love the most about Whimzees is that they have a short ingredient list that are high-quality. There are no artificial flavors, preservatives, GMO’s, gluten, or meat. Plus, they are high in fiber for a healthy GI Tract. There are six primary ingredients found in Whimzees Dog Treats and five secondary ingredients. That’s it! Here is a list of all of the ingredients.

Primary Ingredients:

  1. Potato Starch
  2. Glycerin
  3. Powdered Cellulose
  4. Lecithin
  5. Malt Extract

Secondary Ingredients

  1. Yeast
  2.  Alfalfa Extract
  3. Paprika
  4. Malt Extract
  5. Calcium Carbonate
  6. Clove Bud Oil

Greenies Ingredients

Greenies are made in the USA with ingredients sourced from all over the world. Unlike Whimzees, Greenies are available in various flavors that suit different doggie needs. So, not all of them are made with the same ingredients. To make things easier, we will review the ingredients in the Original Regular Size Dental Treats.

Primary Ingredients:

  1. Wheat Flour
  2. Wheat Gluten
  3. Glycerin
  4. Gelatin
  5. Oat Fiber
  6. Water
  7. Lecithin

Secondary Ingredients:

  1. Natural Poultry Flavor
  2. Minerals
  3. Choline Chloride
  4. Dried Apple Pomace
  5. Fruit Juice Color
  6. Vitamins
  7. Turmeric Color

Whimzees vs. Greenies

Where Are They Made?

Whimzees- Whimzees are made in Holland, which is a region in the Netherlands. Now, we know a lot of pet owners look for treats and other products that are made in the USA. However, Whimzees has a facility in Holland, which has received the highest possible AA rating from the British Retail Consortium made available through the Global Standard for Food Safety.

Greenies- On the other hand, Greenies are made in the USA. They are manufactured in a facility in Kansas City, Missouri since 1996. However, their ingredients are sourced from around the world.

Variety

Whimzees – Brushzees, Stix, Hedgehog, Crossbone, Alligator, Veggie Ear, Rice Bone, Veggie Strip, and Veggie Sausage.

Greenies – Original, Blueberry, Fresh, Grain-free, Weight Management, and Hip and Joint.

Price

We have researched the prices of Greenies and Whimzees on Amazon to help you decide which one would be more financially right for you and your pup. Here is what we found:

 Whimzees Alligator (Amazons Choice) –

 

Small – The small pack comes with 24 treats. The price of these are originally priced around $23.

Medium – This pack comes with12 treats and are priced around $20.

Large – The large pack comes with 6 treats and costs around $17.

They also come in a small, medium, and large variety pack, which costs a bit more. However, your pup will be able to enjoy different shapes each time. So, if you have a few extra dollars to spend this could be a fun option!

Small Variety Pack– This pack has 56 treats for around $29.

Medium Variety Pack– 28 treats for around $35.

Large Variety Pack– 14 treats for around $33.

Greenies Orignal –

We found Amazons Choice where you can get a value pack of 36 oz. of each size. All of these costs the same, which is around $40.

Teenie (51-15lbs.) – The teenie sized pack comes with 130 treats.

Petite (15-25lbs.) – The petite sized pack comes with 60 treats.

Regular (25-50lbs.) –The regular pack comes with 36 treats.

Large (50-100lbs.) – This pack comes with 24 treats.

Overview

There are both up and downs for both of these dental dog treats. Here is an overview of what we like and what we don’t like about Whimzees and Greenies.

Whimzees

What We Like:

  • Simple natural ingredients
  • No artificial ingredients, colors, flavors or preservatives or GMOs, gluten or meat.
  • Comes in fun shapes
  • Low in calories
  • The grooves of the treat get into small crevices of dog’s teeth

What We Don’t Like:

  • You don’t get many treats, especially in the large size for what it costs.
  • Many consumers prefer treats that are made in the USA.
Greenies

What We Like:

  • Made in the USA.
  • You get a lot more treats in each pack.
  • They have special made treats for weight, joints, and more to meet the needs of all dogs.
  • Fortified with added vitamins and minerals to deliver complete and balanced nutrition.
  • Comes in four different sizes rather than three for those extra tiny dogs.
  • Has various flavors so dogs are attracted to them.

What We Don’t Like:

  • Contains more ingredients than Whimzees, which increases the risk of food sensitivities and allergies in dogs.
  • You are supposed to give your dog a Greenie every day in order for them to work properly.

Overall Decision

the winner is…Whimzees Dental Dog Treats!

We find that these are less costly, more effective, and not only meets the needs of dental issues but also other health related concerns. Although we do like Greenies as well, they did have prior issues with their ingredients in recent years. However, they did change their formula and no reports have been made.