Making your own dog treats is a great way to keep the ingredients simple and natural. However, it can become a hassle to have to purchase and prepare all of the individual ingredients. Instead, a simple yet natural alternative is the Whisk and Wag Natural Dog Treat Baking Mix. Baking can be lots of fun, and now you can let Fido enjoy the delicious results! With these natural dog treat mixes, almost everything you need comes right in the jar, so you won’t have to do a last minute grocery run. In our review, we’ll talk about the company, the pros and cons of the mix, and give you all the information you’re looking for.

Table of Contents

About Whisk and Wag Natural Dog Treat Mix

Main Benefits

  • Promotes healthy skin and coat
  • Supports gut, immune, and bone health
  • Great for holidays and birthdays
  • Brings friends and family together
  • Made in the USA

This dog treat baking mix allows you to make your own dog treats, without the hassle of buying the ingredients. All you need is oil and water, and you’ll soon have home-made dog treats! In addition, it comes in a reusable jar for storing treats or any other items. Not to mention, the mix includes a heart shaped cookie cutter, so you can actually put your love into the treats! Fortunately, the shelf life of the unused mix is a year, so you don’t have to worry about using it right away. 

The Whisk and Wag Natural Dog Treat Baking Mix is made with healthy ingredients, and never made with wheat or corn. Depending on which flavor you choose, the ingredients will vary a little. The flavors include peanut butter and berry, sweet potato and spice, honey and oats, and apple and cinnamon. 


Ultimately, the directions are pretty simple for making these dog treats. The instructions tell you the temperature to set your oven, how much water and oil to use, the baking time, along with other little details. As suggested by Whisk and Wag, you should use either vegetable or canola oil. Make sure you have this on hand when planning your dog treat baking day. 

Once you’ve combined the ingredients, you can use a teaspoon to round the dough into balls. Then, press the dough to about ¼ inch thickness with a 1 ½ inch diameter. To use your heart-shaped cookie cutter, you can use a rolling pin to flatten the dough into a sheet to cut from. Take into consideration that the treats will take up to 20-25 minutes to bake. As a result, you’ll have about 25 dog treats for your pooch.

Baking Tip: When the mix, water, and oil are combined, it should have the consistency of cookie dough. If it’s too dry or crumbly, Whisk and Wag suggest adding one tablespoon of water at a time until you get the right texture. 


After your dog treats are finished baking, you’ll need to let them cool for 20 minutes before feeding them to Fido or storing them. The last thing you want is to burn your pup’s mouth, ouch! Once they’ve cooled, you can let your pooch enjoy their delicious, home-made treats. They’ll be sure to taste the love you put into them, especially if you use the heart-shaped cookie cutter. Also, these treats will be good for about a week after baking. 

Whisk and Wag Flavor Options

Peanut Butter and Berry


Oat flour, brewers liquid yeast, soybean meal, peanut butter, sodium bicarbonate, dried cranberry, dried blueberry, and salt

Guaranteed Analysis 

Crude Protein (min) 28%, Crude Fat (min) 4%, Crude Fiber (max) 4%, Moisture (max) 10%

Honey and Oats


Oat flour, brewers liquid yeast, canola meal, rolled oats, honey, rice starch, sodium bicarbonate, and salt

Guaranteed Analysis 

Crude Protein (min) 10%, Crude Fat (min) 15%, Crude Fiber (max) 5%, Moisture (max) 20%

Sweet Potato and Spice

Buying tip: This product is currently not available on Amazon.


Oat flour, brewers liquid yeast, soybean meal, dried sweet potato, sodium bicarbonate, salt, cinnamon, dried ginger

Guaranteed Analysis

Crude Protein (min) 17%, Crude Fat (min) 16%, Crude Fiber (max) 14%, Moisture (max) 24%

Apple and Cinnamon

Buying tip: This product is currently not available on Amazon.


Ingredients: Oat flour, brewers liquid yeast, canola meal, apple powder, cinnamon, baking soda, salt

Guaranteed Analysis 

Crude Protein (min) 10%, Crude Fat (min) 15%, Crude Fiber (max) 7%, Moisture (max) 26%


All Natural

It’s not everyday that you find dog treats with all-natural ingredients. As a dog parent, it’s always a pleasant surprise to see a product with “all natural” on the label. That being said, we consider this a high quality product for Fido! Their mix only uses natural ingredients, to give your dog the benefits they deserve. 

Promotes healthy skin and coat 

Although grooming is the ultimate way to keep your dog’s skin and coat healthy, it also depends on their diet. Fortunately, these dog treats are great for keeping your dogs skin and fur in good shape. Pups don’t get daily baths like humans, so incorporating the right ingredients in their diet is ideal for their health. 

Supports gut, immune, and bone health

Essentially, these dog treats support your pup’s overall health. When feeding your dog a treat, you obviously want it to be digestible. With these treats, they support gut and digestive health, so you can be sure they will digest them properly. In addition, they promote your dog’s immune health, which is important for fighting illnesses. Lastly, these dog treats are ideal for strengthening your dog’s bones. 

Great for Holidays and Birthdays

Although these treats are great for any day of the year, they also are perfect for celebrating special occasions. During the holiday season, baking is an all too common activity for humans. Whether it’s Thanksgiving, Christmas, or Hanukkah, you’ll probably find yourself eating some sort of baked goods. 

Lots of people food isn’t safe for Fido to eat, but we know you don’t want to leave them out on the fun. Instead, this dog treat baking mix will be safe and come in handy during those days spent baking. Or, you could even make these treats to celebrate your dog’s birthday! To see more about spoiling your dog on their special day, head on over to our article How to Celebrate Your Dog’s Birthday. 

Brings Friends and Family Together

Baking is a fun activity to enjoy with friends and family. Children can participate and learn new things, all while making a healthy treat for Fido. Spending time with your friends and family is truly priceless, which is why we love the idea behind these treats. Plus, this will make for an ideal rainy-day activity. When the weather is dreary, baking is the perfect activity for staying dry inside!

Made in the USA

Staying close to the source of where you purchase dog products is a huge bonus, especially for dog food and treats. When products are made in the USA, the company must comply with USA rules and regulations. That being said, it makes the products much safer for you pup. As a result, it’s easier to trust the company and their products. Specifically, Whisk and Wag’s products are made in Ohio. Not only does being made in the USA make it safer, but you’ll also be supporting local businesses and our economy. 

If you want to see more USA-made dog products, take a look at The Best Companies for Made in the USA Dog Products. 


Baked Treats Have a Short Shelf Life

Once you’ve baked the dog treats, Whisk and Wag says they are best used in one week. Unfortunately, that’s a pretty short time for a shelf life. However, that is a sacrifice for purchasing all natural dog products that don’t have preservatives. Since the mix makes about 25 treats, that’s a lot to feet your dog in one week, unless you have more than one dog. On the other hand, the mix itself will last up to a year when unopened. If you want to extend the shelf life of your dog treats, Whisk and Wag suggests refrigerating or freezing them.

Do We Recommend this Dog Treat Baking Mix?

If you’re a newbie when it comes to making your own dog treats, we highly suggest trying out this dog treat mix. Truly, making your own dog treats doesn’t get any simpler than this. The mix is already made for you, without you needing to gather a laundry list of groceries. On the other hand, if you’re looking to do it the old fashioned way, this won’t be the perfect option for you.

About the Whisk and Wag Brand

Whisk and Wag is a brand under the F.L. Emmert Company. This is a family-owned, 5th generation company that’s been around for 135 years. Known for their high quality nutritional ingredients for animals, Emmert is the source of ingredients for Whisk and Wag. Whisk and Wag brings their ingredients to their kitchen, where they create their natural dog treat baking mix. Ideally, Whisk and Wag strives to give customers the quality of natural ingredients, and believes making homemade treats should be a joy, not a task.